[Hardware] Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W Review: The Long Awaited Sequel

[Agent47]

 

 

I remember my first Raspberry Pi Zero, from the cover of The MagPi which I bought at Paddington train station, the day before the official launch. That was 2015 and the single core 1-GHz CPU with 512MB RAM was enough for basic tasks. For $5, we all fell in love with the smallest and cheapest Raspberry Pi. Since then we have seen the Raspberry Pi 3B, 3B+ and the all powerful Raspberry Pi 4 join the family. All of these boards have a quad core CPU in common, leaving the Raspberry Pi Zero’s single core CPU for simple embedded projects.

There have been three models of Raspberry Pi Zero. The original model lacked a camera connector, rectified via an updated model. But we would have to wait until 2017 for Wi-Fi and Bluetooth to reach the Zero. The Raspberry Pi Zero W was a little more expensive at $10, but worth it for the wireless connectivity.

The year is 2021 and after six long years we finally see a CPU update to the Raspberry Pi Zero range. The Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W is a $15 quad core Arm Cortex A53, similar to that of the Raspberry Pi 3, in fact they share the same BCM2710A1 die, but the Zero 2 W is underclocked to 1 GHz on all cores. We were lucky enough to get hands on with the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W, months ahead of its launch and we put it through its paces to see if it is worth the extra $5.
What hit us first about the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W is the form factor. It is identical to all of the previous Zero models. In this case the lack of change is for the better as it means we can drop the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W into our existing projects and cases. The 40 pin GPIO is a common feature of the brand, but the smaller size of the Raspberry Pi Zero initially brought with it a few compromises. We have a single mini HDMI port and two micro USB ports for power and USB 2.0. On the right edge of the board is a smaller camera (CSI) connector which when used with an adapter cable enables the use of any official Raspberry Pi camera.
So with this lack of change, does it mean that our old Raspberry Pi Zero cases will fit? We checked the official Raspberry Pi Zero case and it fits like a glove. Snapping into place onto four plastic spacers. If you wish to use the camera case lid, make sure that the GPIO is unsoldered, otherwise it will make contact with the Pi Zero 2 W.
Other cases, such as the laser cut acrylic Pibow cases from Pimoroni look to have an issue with the third layer of the laser cut case. On the original Raspberry Pi Zero there are a series of power circuitry components which have been moved for the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W. The large silver square, part of the wireless connectivity for the Pi Zero 2 W, is also a big obstacle for the Pibow case. No doubt Pimoroni will update the case ready for launch.
The added performance of the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W does see it draw a little more power, something to factor into your projects. The Raspberry Pi Zero W draws around 260mA at idle and 370mA when stressed using Stressberry. The same test on the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W and we saw 280mA at idle and 580mA under stress. 

Those extra cores certainly add up. When integrating the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W into your project, ensure that you have more than enough power for the Pi and any other devices.

Using the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W 
Straight off the bat, the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W is not a desktop replacement Pi. So don’t expect it to replace your beloved Raspberry Pi 2 / 3 or 4. What you can expect is for the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W to replace the Pi Zero in your embedded projects. The form factor is identical to the Zero’s that came before it, so you can drop this into an existing project with little or no config. 
The Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W comes with the standard 40 pin GPIO, of course you will need to get your soldering iron ready, or invest in some of Pimoroni’s Hammer Headers.

We installed the current version of Raspberry Pi OS 32-bit, and proceeded to power on and test a series of HATs. First on the list is Pimoroni’s Explorer HAT Pro, a board we are extremely accustomed to after leading 25+ Picademy training sessions where we used it to teach students. Explorer HAT Pro installed and ran without a hitch and so did the pHAT version. 

We then tested Raspberry Pi’s own Sense HAT and it worked with no issues. Suffice it to say that, if you have any Raspberry Pi HATs or add-ons, you can run them on the Pi Zero 2 W with the exception of the PoE HAT and PoE HAT+ which require the PoE header pins only present on the 3B+ and 4. We also tested the official Raspberry Pi Camera with the Zero 2 W and are happy to report that it worked as expected.

Advertisement

The Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W has the same BCM2710A1 die as the Raspberry Pi 3, but don’t expect Pi 3 performance. With half the RAM of a Pi 3B, 512MB, we can get the basics done such as coding via Thonny, basic web browsing and a few games of Minecraft Pi Edition. 

Streaming video on YouTube is not a good experience as in our tests it failed to play a clip at even 720p resolution. Performance improved once we connected a USB to Ethernet dongle, but we still saw frequent pauses and stutters. Wi-Fi is competent but do consider that this is a PCB antenna so you will need to be near a strong access point.
The Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W comes with four cores running at a stock 1 GHz, and the increase in cores and speed translates to an increase in heat. At idle, the Pi Zero 2 sits at 36.5 Celsius, compared to the Raspberry Pi Zero W which idles at 32.6 Celsius. That’s not a big difference in temperature, but when we used Stressberry, we saw the Pi Zero 2’s temperature rise to a high of 63.4 Celsius, much higher than the Pi Zero W’s 44.4 Celsius.  

Advertisement

For reference we ran Stressberry on a Raspberry Pi 3B and saw an idle temperature of 40.8 Celsius, and Stressberry high of 80.1 Celsius! We took our test up a notch and ran a tortue test to see when the Raspberry Pi would thermally throttle. With the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W overclocked to 1.4 GHz and inside the official Raspberry Pi Zero case we ran stressberry and saw the temperature rise to 75.2 Celsius and then the system locked up hard. We rebooted and everything was ok but it is fair to say that taking your Pi to the extreme will require cooling.

Can adding a heatsink help the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W reach a lower temperature? The short answer is yes. With a Raspberry Pi sized heatsink attached, in our Stressberry test, we reached a high of 56.9 Celsius, and the idle temperature remained at 36.5 Celsius. The 6.5 Celsius temperature difference between the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W without and with a heatsink is not earth shattering and the higher temperature in no way impacts performance. 

To further lower the temperature, we would need a form of active cooling and Pimoroni’s Fan Shim sprang to mind, but there is a problem. Pimoroni’s Fan Shim may fit comfortably on the GPIO, but the placement of the fan over the SoC is not optimal. It covers the SoC but hangs over the footprint of the Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W. 

The active cooling provided by the Fan Shim did drop our temperatures considerably. With an idle temperature of 26.8 Celsius, almost 8 degrees cooler than a stock Pi Zero 2, and under load, the top temperature hit 39.2 Celsius, 24.2 degrees cooler than stock. If you intend to work your Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W hard, then some form of cooling is a must.